Friday, September 23, 2005

Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal?

Controversy
During the first decade of the 19th century the agents of Lord Thomas Elgin (British Ambassador to Constantinople 1799-1803) removed whole boatloads of ancient sculpture from Greece's capital city of Athens. The pride of this collection was a large amount of fifth-century BC sculpture taken from the Parthenon, the temple to the goddess Athena, which stood on the Acropolis hill in the centre of the city.
The Parthenon sculpture included about a half (some 75 metres) of the sculpted frieze that once ran all round the building, plus 17 life-sized marble figures from its gable ends (or pediments) and 15 of the 92 metopes, or sculpted panels, originally displayed high up above its columns.
'These actions were controversial from the very beginning.'
These actions were controversial from the very beginning. Even before all the sculptures - soon known as the Elgin Marbles - went on display in London, Lord Byron attacked Elgin in stinging verses, lamenting (in 'Childe Harold's Pilgrimage') how the antiquities of Greece had been 'defac'd by British hands'.
Others enthusiastically welcomed the arrival of the sculpture in London. John Keats penned a sonnet to celebrate 'Seeing the Elgin Marbles' in the British Museum, and from Germany, JW Goethe hailed their acquisition as 'the beginning of a new age for Great Art'.Debate

Portrait of Lord Elgin © Since then, there has been a never-ending international debate about Elgin's removal of the sculptures, and whether they should be returned to Athens. Sometimes this can give the impression of an unseemly scrap over a favourite toy, with petulant cries of 'we want' being balanced by an equally unappealing refusal to let go. There certainly have been bad, as well as good, arguments on all sides. But the real reason that the dispute has lasted so long is that it raises important and difficult issues, and it is not easy to see what a fair resolution is.
'Do monuments such as the Parthenon belong to the whole world?'
There are many factors behind this. We do not know if Elgin's actions were legal at the time. He had obtained from the Turkish authorities then in control of Athens permission to work on the Acropolis, but only an Italian translation of this firman(or permit) survives and its terms are disputed.
Nor is it possible to reconstruct Elgin's motives. Some evidence suggests that he was a self-serving aristocrat, seeking sculpture to decorate his ancestral pile. Some say that he was genuinely concerned to rescue these works of art. But the main difficulty lies in the much bigger issue of 'cultural property' in general. Who owns great works of art? Do monuments such as the Parthenon belong to the whole world? And what does that mean in practice?The Parthenon in 1800

The Parthenon When Elgin's men removed the sculpture from the Parthenon, the building was in a very sorry state. From the fifth century BC to the 17th century AD, it had been in continuous use. It was built as a Greek temple, was later converted into a Christian church, and finally (with the coming of Turkish rule over Greece in the 15th century) it was turned into a mosque.
Although we think of it primarily as a pagan temple, its history as church and mosque was an even longer one, and no less distinguished. It was, as one British traveller put it in the mid-17th century, 'the finest mosque in the world'.
All that changed in 1687 when, during fighting between Venetians and Turks, a Venetian cannonball hit the Parthenon mosque - temporarily in use as a gunpowder store. Some 300 women and children were amongst those killed, and the building itself was ruined. By 1800 a small replacement mosque had been erected inside the shell, while the surviving fabric and sculpture was suffering the predictable fate of many ancient ruins.
'On the one hand, the local population was using it as a convenient quarry.'
On the one hand, the local population was using it as a convenient quarry. A good deal of the original sculpture, as well as the plain building blocks, were reused in local housing or ground down for cement. On the other hand, increasing numbers of travellers and antiquarians from northern Europe were busily helping themselves to anything they could pocket (hence the scattering of pieces of Parthenon sculpture around European museums from Copenhagen to Strasbourg) - and among these collectors was Lord Elgin.
Whatever Elgin's motives, there is no doubt at all that he saved his sculpture from worse damage. However, in prising out some of the pieces that still remained in place, his agents inevitably inflicted further damage on the fragile ruin.The Acropolis

The Birtish Museum The Acropolis hill today is a bare rock, on which are perched the famous monuments of the fifth century BC - including the Parthenon. There is the tiny temple of Victory, which stands by the propylaia, or main gateway, to the hilltop, and also the so-called Erechtheum, another shrine of Athena, with its famous line-up of caryatids (columns in the form of female figures). One of the caryatids is now, thanks to Elgin, in the British Museum.
In Elgin's day it was quite different. The Parthenon stood in the middle of the small village-cum-garrison base that then occupied the hill. It was encroached upon by houses and gardens, and by all kinds of Byzantine, medieval and Renaissance remains. It is quite wrong to imagine Elgin removing works of art from the equivalent of a modern archaeological site - it was more of a seedy shanty town.
'It is quite wrong to imagine Elgin removing works of art from the equivalent of a modern archaeological site - it was more of a seedy shanty town.'
This changed dramatically in the 1830s, after the Greek War of Independence which ended Turkish rule in Greece. The young Bavarian prince, Otto, who was put on the throne of the new Greek nation, was confronted with terrible problems - not least of which was how to find the patriotic symbols for a new country that had just experienced a dreadfully brutal war.
It is clear that Otto's classically-educated advisers saw the culture of ancient Athens as a valuable card here. Athens was chosen as the capital city and (once the plan to build the royal palace on the Acropolis had been rejected) a systematic programme of excavations began. In the course of this, everything that did not belong to the 'great' period of the fifth century BC was removed. The hill was stripped to bedrock, with just the classical monuments preserved or reconstructed, to serve as a symbol of the new nation's heroic past.
There is no doubt that today the status of the Parthenon as a Greek national monument is an important factor in the campaign to restore the Elgin Marbles to Greece. The complicating paradox is that the Parthenon was not a national monument when those same sculptures were removed.London story
Meanwhile in London, the Elgin Marbles started a new chapter of their history -- as museum objects. Acquiring the sculptures had bankrupted Elgin, and he was keen to sell them to the government. In 1816 a Parliamentary Select Committee looked into the whole affair (examining everything from the quality of the sculpture as works of art to the legality of their acquisition) and recommended purchase, though for much less money than Elgin had hoped. From that point on the sculptures have been lodged in the British Museum.
Over the last 200 years they have come to 'belong' in the British Museum and are now historically rooted there as well as in Athens. Not only were they an important part of British 19th-century culture (inspiring Keats and others, and prompting replicas of themselves across the country), but they are also integral to the whole idea of the Universal Museum and the way museums over the last two centuries have come to display and interpret human culture.
'Over the last 200 years they have come to 'belong' in the British Museum and are now historically rooted there as well as in Athens.'
The museum movement depended on collection, on moving objects from their original location, and on allowing them to be understood in relation to different traditions of art and cultural forms. In the British Museum, the Elgin Marbles gain from being seen next to Assyrian or Egyptian sculpture, at the same time as they lose from not being 'at home in Greece'.
This is what causes the irresolvable conflict - it has turned out that there is more than one place that can legitimately call itself 'home' to the Elgin Marbles.Cultural property?

The Battle of Lapiths and Centaurs © The battle of the Marbles has been fought on many fronts. The weaker arguments do neither side much credit. Both the Greeks and the British have accused each other of not caring properly for their precious charges. And there have been outbreaks of vulgar nationalism (reaching a low point when one Director of the British Museum claimed that the campaign for the return of the Marbles was a form of 'cultural fascism' - 'it's like burning books').
The stronger arguments tend to reveal just how complicated the dilemmas are. There is a powerful case for suggesting that the Parthenon could be better appreciated if it could be seen close to the sculptures that once adorned it. (Though environmental conditions in Athens mean that the original sculptures can never go back on the building itself.) On the other hand, it is undeniable that part of the fame and significance of the Parthenon rests on its wide diaspora throughout the western world.
'The likelihood is that we will be debating these issues for many years to come.'
Ultimately it comes down to matters of ownership, and how the world's great cultural icons are to be shared. In the performing arts that problem is relatively easy to solve. Shakespeare might have a special connection with Stratford, and Mozart with Vienna - but we can all 'own' their works in performance anywhere in the world.
That is not the case with these blocks of marble. Where do they belong? Is it better or worse to have them scattered through the world? Are they the possession of those who live in the place where they were first made? Or are they the possession of everyone? The likelihood is that we will be debating these issues for many years to come.

16 Comments:

Blogger hplauze said...

Hi Vyli your blog is really great! Wow :-) As I was out blog surfing and surfing the web for detailed info on card credit credit no I stumbled across your blog. Obviously my search landed me here and it is a little off subject compared to Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal?, but I am certainly glad I did come across your blog. Did I already tell you I like it! If you would not mind, I would like to add your link to my "favorites" page to come back and read again sometime. Should you ever need it, there's lots of information on this site about card credit credit no. Again, great blog and keep up the great work!

6:58 AM  
Blogger Rachel said...

I love your blog Vyli. How long has it been on-line? Reason I ask is I am doing a ton of work in the area of card credit free no porn and will probably end up starting a blog of my own. Funny how the internet brought me here when I was doing searches on card credit free no porn. Oh well, I am glad it did. Keep up the great blogging and I am sure I will visit Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? again!!

3:35 PM  
Blogger hplauze said...

Hey Vyli. Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching card credit merchant service. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is way off base from card credit merchant service I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don’t your url and feel free to visit me here at card credit merchant service. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

11:12 AM  
Blogger Rachel said...

Hey Vyli. Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching card credit merchant service. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is way off base from card credit merchant service I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don’t your url and feel free to visit me here at card credit merchant service. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

8:30 PM  
Blogger Rachel said...

Hey Vyli. Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching card credit household. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is way off base from card credit household I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don’t your url and feel free to visit me here at card credit household. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

8:10 AM  
Blogger Derek said...

Well I just got back from the gym and I am beat. I am currently doing some research on accept card credit online and stumbled across your blog. Which cracks me up really. The internet can certainly land you off base sometimes. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is not completely related I think it is a cool blog. I have read back through the archives and lots of people make some very good points. Well I have been on-line forever it seems. I need to continue to plug away at accept card credit online. If you have the energy swing by accept card credit online. I try to update my site weekly and maybe you will see something you like. I already snagged your URL and put it in my favorites. If you do not mind I will be back again. Great job!

4:44 PM  
Blogger Derek said...

Well I just got back from the gym and I am beat. I am currently doing some research on card credit merchant service and stumbled across your blog. Which cracks me up really. The internet can certainly land you off base sometimes. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is not completely related I think it is a cool blog. I have read back through the archives and lots of people make some very good points. Well I have been on-line forever it seems. I need to continue to plug away at card credit merchant service. If you have the energy swing by card credit merchant service. I try to update my site weekly and maybe you will see something you like. I already snagged your URL and put it in my favorites. If you do not mind I will be back again. Great job!

9:52 AM  
Blogger Derek said...

Hey Vyli. Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching card credit payment. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is way off base from card credit payment I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don’t your url and feel free to visit me here at card credit payment. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

4:59 AM  
Blogger cmeltifa said...

All I can say is WOW Vyli. The other half and I just got back from our friends house (well her friends house) and I needed a huge break. I am working on a project right now that is based on card credit household. I have literally been on-line for 2-3 hours doing research. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? really isn’t on the same page as card credit household I am certainly glad I came across your blog. There are a ton of great view points on this blog. Well I think I can here the kids screaming in the background. I put you in my internet favorites and I will certainly come back and visit. If you want to take a peek at my site you can find me here at card credit household. I update my site very frequently. Again, great job blogging and I will be back again soon!

5:57 AM  
Blogger cmeltifa said...

All I can say is WOW Vyli. The other half and I just got back from our friends house (well her friends house) and I needed a huge break. I am working on a project right now that is based on card credit merchant service. I have literally been on-line for 2-3 hours doing research. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? really isn’t on the same page as card credit merchant service I am certainly glad I came across your blog. There are a ton of great view points on this blog. Well I think I can here the kids screaming in the background. I put you in my internet favorites and I will certainly come back and visit. If you want to take a peek at my site you can find me here at card credit merchant service. I update my site very frequently. Again, great job blogging and I will be back again soon!

1:30 PM  
Blogger Rebek said...

Well this blog certainly is not about card credit reader. What the heck! I guess the internet can play some tricks on us sometimes. I have been on-line for two hours
researching card credit reader and came tumbling across your blog. I LOVE IT! I needed a break from card credit reader anyways :-) If you don't mind I want to add your
blog to my favorites list so I can come back later on and read some more stuff. Well I guess I should get back to researching card credit reader.
Even though my search is not on Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? I am glad I came across your blog. Keep blogging away!

9:44 PM  
Blogger Rebek said...

I love your blog Vyli. How long has it been on-line? Reason I ask is I am doing a ton of work in the area of card credit marbles and will probably end up starting a blog of my own. Funny how the internet brought me here when I was doing searches on card credit marbles. Oh well, I am glad it did. Keep up the great blogging and I am sure I will visit Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? again!!

8:06 AM  
Blogger Rebek said...

I love your blog Vyli. How long has it been on-line? Reason I ask is I am doing a ton of work in the area of business card credit small and will probably end up starting a blog of my own. Funny how the internet brought me here when I was doing searches on business card credit small. Oh well, I am glad it did. Keep up the great blogging and I am sure I will visit Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? again!!

4:47 PM  
Blogger cmeltifa said...

Well I just got back from the gym and I am beat. I am currently doing some research on card credit payment and stumbled across your blog. Which cracks me up really. The internet can certainly land you off base sometimes. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is not completely related I think it is a cool blog. I have read back through the archives and lots of people make some very good points. Well I have been on-line forever it seems. I need to continue to plug away at card credit payment. If you have the energy swing by card credit payment. I try to update my site weekly and maybe you will see something you like. I already snagged your URL and put it in my favorites. If you do not mind I will be back again. Great job!

8:02 PM  
Blogger cmeltifa said...

Hey Vyli. Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching card credit free no porn. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is way off base from card credit free no porn I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don’t your url and feel free to visit me here at card credit free no porn. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

5:59 AM  
Blogger Rachel said...

Well I just got back from the gym and I am beat. I am currently doing some research on card credit debt management and stumbled across your blog. Which cracks me up really. The internet can certainly land you off base sometimes. Even though Lord Elgin - Saviour or Vandal? is not completely related I think it is a cool blog. I have read back through the archives and lots of people make some very good points. Well I have been on-line forever it seems. I need to continue to plug away at card credit debt management. If you have the energy swing by card credit debt management. I try to update my site weekly and maybe you will see something you like. I already snagged your URL and put it in my favorites. If you do not mind I will be back again. Great job!

9:12 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home